Are You Really Self-Employed? What Every Independent Carer Needs to Know About Employment Status and IR35
Some people say IR35 doesn't affect carers at all. Others insist every self-employed carer is at risk. The truth sits somewhere in the middle — here's what IR35 actually is, who it applies to, and why most independent carers working directly with private families are unlikely to be affected.
Last reviewed: July 2026
If you've spent any time in self-employed care groups, you've probably seen people mention IR35.
Some people say it doesn't affect carers at all.
Others insist every self-employed carer is at risk.
The truth sits somewhere in the middle.
For most genuinely independent carers working directly with private families, IR35 is unlikely to be an issue. However, understanding what it is can help you avoid problems if your working arrangements change in the future.
What is IR35?
IR35 (officially called the off-payroll working rules) is tax legislation designed to stop people avoiding employment taxes by working through a company while effectively behaving like an employee.
In simple terms, HMRC asks:
"If we removed your limited company from the picture, would you really be an employee?"
If the answer is yes, HMRC may decide that employment taxes should have been paid.
The rules were introduced to tackle "disguised employment", not genuine self-employment.
Does IR35 affect sole traders?
Usually, no.
Most self-employed carers operate as sole traders, not through their own limited company (often called a Personal Service Company or PSC).
IR35 generally applies where someone provides their services through an intermediary, such as their own limited company.
If you're a sole trader working directly with families, IR35 is generally not the legislation that determines your status.
That said, HMRC can still decide whether someone is genuinely self-employed or employed under general employment status rules.
When might a carer need to think about IR35?
You may need to consider it if you:
- operate through your own limited company
- contract with agencies or larger care providers through that company
- provide services to NHS organisations, councils or larger businesses through your company.
For medium and large organisations, the client is normally responsible for deciding whether the engagement falls inside or outside the off-payroll rules. Small private-sector clients are generally exempt from making that determination, meaning responsibility often remains with the contractor's company.
What makes someone look like an employee?
HMRC doesn't rely on one single factor.
Instead, it looks at the overall working relationship.
Questions include:
Who controls the work?
Do you decide how you provide care? Or does someone dictate exactly what you must do and how you must do it?
Greater control by the client points towards employment.
Can you send someone else?
If you're genuinely running a business, you may have the ability to arrange another suitably qualified person to carry out the work (where appropriate and agreed).
If only you can ever perform the work, this may point more towards employment.
Are you financially at risk?
Businesses normally carry some financial risk. Examples include:
- paying for your own training
- supplying equipment
- correcting mistakes at your own expense
- having periods without work.
Employees generally do not carry these risks.
Do you work for several clients?
Having multiple clients generally supports self-employment.
Working full-time for one organisation for years in exactly the same way as employees may suggest something different.
Why this matters for carers
Private care is incredibly varied.
One self-employed carer may:
- advertise independently
- choose their own clients
- negotiate their own fees
- provide services to several families
- decide when they work.
Another may:
- work exclusively for one organisation
- follow staff rotas
- have no control over fees
- work under close supervision
- appear almost identical to employed staff.
Although both may describe themselves as "self-employed", HMRC may not necessarily see them the same way.
What about Introduction Agencies?
This is where things become particularly interesting.
Many care introduction agencies carefully structure their arrangements so carers contract directly with families.
That does not automatically make every arrangement genuinely self-employed.
HMRC looks beyond labels.
The reality of the working relationship matters more than what the contract calls it.
This is one reason carers should always understand exactly who they are contracting with and how much independence they genuinely have.
Recent developments
There have been no major changes to the core IR35 rules for carers in 2026, although HMRC has continued updating its guidance and support. New guidance published during 2026 includes clarification around student loan deductions where the off-payroll rules apply, and HMRC has continued expanding guidance for employment intermediaries.
Separate umbrella company PAYE rules came into force from April 2026, but these are different from IR35 and mainly affect labour supply chains using umbrella companies rather than genuinely self-employed carers working directly with families.
Practical tips
If you're considering self-employment:
- Understand whether you're a sole trader or limited company.
- Read every contract carefully.
- Keep evidence that you genuinely run your own business.
- Avoid assuming that simply being "called self-employed" settles the issue.
- If you're unsure, seek advice from a qualified accountant or tax adviser before signing long-term contracts.
The bottom line
For most independent carers working directly with private families as sole traders, IR35 is unlikely to be the issue that keeps you awake at night.
However, understanding the principles behind it helps you recognise the difference between genuine self-employment and arrangements that may look independent on paper but resemble employment in practice.
The more control you have over your business, your clients and the way you work, the stronger the case that you are genuinely operating as an independent professional.
Disclaimer: This article provides general information only and should not be relied upon as tax or legal advice. Every working arrangement is different. If you are unsure about your employment status or tax obligations, seek advice from a qualified accountant or tax professional.
Get your records organised for tax season
The Tax Confidence Kit helps you organise income, expenses, mileage, invoices and receipts into one clear, printable pack for Self Assessment or an accountant meeting. It's a Pro Carer Circle member tool — sign in with a Pro Carer Circle account to use it.
Practical support, written agreements and real-world tools.
JCC is a resource hub for independent care — not an agency. Choose the area that fits where you are right now.
Keep reading
Private Sick Pay for Self-Employed Carers
"Anyone pay for private sick pay?" If you're self-employed, you've probably seen the ads. When you're a live-in carer earning weekly, the thought of having no income at all if you're ill is frightening — but private sick pay isn't always what you think it is.
Tax & National Insurance for Self-Employed Carers
If you're working as a self-employed carer, you are not "avoiding" tax — you are responsible for handling it yourself. That's very different, and once you understand how it works, it's far less scary than it sounds.
Making Tax Digital (MTD) for Self-Employed Carers
Why It Matters More Than You Think. If you're self-employed, Making Tax Digital isn't optional. It's not "something accountants deal with." And it's definitely not something to ignore. It's coming — and for many carers, it will change how you manage your income entirely.